I think there are thousands upon thousands of riders that would disagree.
Just look at the market share of US HD sales compared to rest of manufacturers... currently 54.9%. 'Nuff said.
I get the fact that you absolutely abhor all Harleys except the VRod, and maybe the Street, because they are old technology. But for some, that is the very reason they like them. Simplistic and traditional... oh, and the air-cooled Harley sound.
Maybe some day HD will build a "modern" touring bike, but I wouldn't hold my breath, it was 12 years between the intro of the "modern" VRod to the new Street models, so evolution seems awful slow. But at least you have your BMW to ride until then, so it's all good, right?